Montecristo 1970 Dunhill Selección Suprema No.4

[jazznut]

Montecristo 1970 Dunhill Selección Suprema No.4

Country of fabrication: Cuba
Dimensions: 5.13 inches by 42-ring gauge
Date smoked: August 25th, 2007

Saturday morning showers succumbed to a sunlit afternoon bordering on the tropical. Beads of moisture coursed over my forehead, a container filled with freshly picked blackberries providing ample reward for my sweat-laden state. I felt the time to settle back on the front lawn of the cottage with a fine cigar and a soothing beverage long overdue. The moment was ripe for something special.

I poured a healthy measure of C. Ferrand’s Reserve Old Artisanal Rum, a deliciously honeyed spirit from Venezuela, distilled in 1992 and bottled in 2004, then clipped the cap of the venerable Mareva I had chosen to set fire to.

The diminutive cigar sported a natural walnut toned Colorado outer leaf embellished with reddish sienna highlights as well as scattered burnt umber markings. The finely veined and discreetly toothed wrapper of the No.4 gave off a lovely oil-imbued semi-gloss sheen in the sunshine, seeming far younger than its 37 years of age. This Petit Corona had clearly been cared for. A medium firm finger feel allied to excellent superficial resilience further reinforced my impression of healthiness.

Beneath the cylindrically formed surface, a burnt sienna binder secured the filler leaves, which varied in hue from straw through to rather dark chocolate brown.

Appearances aside, it was the aroma of the Montecristo that instantly won me over. Prior to lighting, a scent of sweet woods tightly bound with hints of apple and leather, subtle earthy nuances artfully completing the picture. Following firing, deeply toasted tobacco of the ripest sort imaginable wafted from the pale grey to ruddy charcoal ash upward into the breeze. I believe only age can create such a wondrously composed, perfumed and intoxicating fragrance.

On the palate, the Selección Suprema opened with a finely delineated interplay of cedar, citrus and old leather, displaying great vitality throughout the overture. The flavour spectrum soon broadened, well cured and mature tobacco softly fleshing out the profile. Sweetness and smoothness, not unlike a melding of clover honey and walnut butter, provided a perfect counterpoint to the more sharply etched cedar and citrus components.

Lying slightly to the light side of medium in terms of its textural weight, the Mareva nonetheless projected an underlying sensation of strength. The tannins of youth having almost entirely dissipated, residual acidity was left to act as the primary foil to the mature ripeness of the core tobacco aspect, resulting in a more clearly fashioned and elegant sense of balance and proportion.

From mid point on, a lovely plum fruit quality emerged while subdued vegetal and floral notes began to seep into the cedar. The cigar simultaneously gained in body. Then, an absolute surprise – beans! Not just any beans, mind you, but the distinct taste of red azuki beans such as one encounters in a sweet Chinese dessert soup. The effect was both uncannily evocative and precise. I was floored.

As my puffs brought the Montecristo closer and closer to its demise, a peppery piquancy arrived on the palate to lend the proceedings an additional liveliness. Even though little more than an hour had elapsed, I found myself in a tremendously relaxed, timeless frame of mind. Pure magic.

I don’t think I’ll ever again look upon a Montecristo No.4 in quite the same way.

A footnote: Far from being a collector of vintage cigars, I owe the pleasure of this rare cigar experience to a certain supremely generous gentleman who resides here on the Cigar Weekly boards. And so let me take this opportunity to simply say, "Thank you, Phil!"

[mrkmitch]

A very profound review of a rare and intrinsically sublime smoke . I would think most anything, kept well, and with 37+ years aging is going to be smooth and developed, but particularlly this very special smoke. Your review of this special Monte #4 brings hope for my diminutive, yet varied, long term storage of my special smokes.

Thanks for another great review

[PCaponi]

Doug, the pleasure was mine. Truly one of the finest reviews ever written.

[tick_tn]

WOW. Gotta get outta work now....must smoke....

[JulietasRomeo]

Outstanding!!!! Very generous of you Phil, and as always Doug, excellent review

[Coach]

i smoked one of these!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! finally a cigar that i can relate too with Doug. Truly an exceptional cigar,it went well with the MC/Dunhill blended lines of the late 70's. I have also had the pleasure of smoking a Monte/Dunhill #2 along with Caponi and Clanceydabulldog at my house. Same taste notes were there. I had the No. 4 2 weeks ago at another Herf, while there I also got to taste the Partigas/Dunhill blend and 2 Dunhill Tubos.

[PCaponi]

I have to find some sweet Chinese soup.

[HoyoPR]

Thanks for an excellently written review, I'm still quite new and haven't collected much in the line of aged cigars. Do you know what the likely hood of finding well aged cigars in the LCDH shops in Havana or Varodaro are? A friend was able to find a box of 2002 while there this past spring and my wife and I hope to travel there in the new year.

[MM]

Thanks for sharing this rare and exquisite cigar smoking experience!