Go Back   Cigar Weekly Community Forums and Discussion Groups > Smoking Post > Cigar Reviews

Cigar Reviews This room is for organized blind reviews, individual reviews by CW Members and reviews entered into the database that the Editors feel are particularly well done.

Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
Old 01-06-2009, 05:10 PM   #1
Mad Dawg
Administrator
Herf Dog
Herf God
 
Mad Dawg's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2002
Location: Republic of Texas
Posts: 34,195
Cigar Weekly blind reviews

Last summer, I took on the task of managing the formal blind reviews that have been a part of Cigar Weekly since the beginning. A total of 7 reviews were published in 2008, and we'll certainly pass that number in 2009. Our esteemed editor TommyBB suggested that it would be a good idea to post some key information about the reviews, so here goes!

The process usually starts when a cigar manufacturer contacts one of CW's owners or editors and indicates an interest in getting some feedback on one of their products. We ask them to provide a minimum of 16 cigars so that I can send 2 each to our 7-member tasting panel, and try a couple myself.

When the cigars get to me, I remove all bands and other packaging (tubos, etc.) that could identify the cigar and send a pair to each of our reviewers. We always want to send two cigars in case one of them is a stinker. You know the one...that crappy cigar that occasionally slips past the quality control process? We send two so that the manufacturer gets a second chance in case we get one of those. It has happened.

In any case, we send a pair to each of our reviewerss Our panel currently consists of 6 permanent members drawn from CW's ranks:

TommyBB
ronin
SLR
flipflop
Fishin' Phil
Elk Twin

Those guys provide a degree of continuity to the reviews.

Beginning in late 2008, we added four rotating members to our tasting panel in order to broaden the base on which our ratings are provided. Our current rotating members are:

AnejoMofo
Augie754
Black Plague
H311oLHD

Those guys provide new and varying input to the reviews.

When they smoke the review cigars, our panelists fill out a form that captures standardized numerical scores and allows free-form comments in three key areas: Pre-Smoke, Smoke, and Summary. Elements like construction, burn, ash, flavor, aroma, and many others, are ranked by each reviewer.

The reviewers then send their completed forms to me. I compile the numerical scores in a spreadsheet I built for the purpose, and transfer their comments (unedited) into my writeup. The numerical scores are totaled for each reviewer, and the high and low scores are tossed out. The average of the remaining scores is the basis for the CW Star rating that we assign each cigar.

Cigar Weekly’s 50 Point Scale:
0 – 9.......1 star...........Not Recommended
10 - 19....2 stars..........Below Average
20 - 29....3 stars..........Average
30 - 34....3 1/2 stars.....Above Average
35 - 39....4 stars...........Excellent
40 - 44....4 1/2 stars.....Outstanding
45 - 50....5 stars...........Superior

I never score the cigars myself, because I necessarily know what they are and I don't want to introduce any question of bias into the final rating. I have offered up my own impressions of reviewed cigars in my write-ups from time to time, but any mental scoring I do is never counted in a cigar's formal rating.

This blind review system is designed to give cigar manufacturers unbiased feedback regarding the quality of their products. By removing any identifying packaging from the cigars, we remove the possibility of brand-based bias and enable the reviewers to focus solely on how the cigars look, feel, smell, and taste. That feedback has proven to be very valuable to manufacturers, and has helped to prevent at least one factory mistake from becoming a PR nightmare.

The finished reviews are sometimes published on the front page, but eventually they all find their way to the Reviews page: http://www.cigarweekly.com/magazine/reviews

The owners, administrators, editors, and moderators of Cigar Weekly hope that these reviews provide useful information for the members of the CW community, as well as to the manufacturers who provide cigars for the reviews.

As a final note, I'd like to say that quality reviews - in any form - are always welcomed and appreciated in this room. We read them all, and in fact that's how we identified potential candidates for the rotating panelist positions. We're always looking for good reviewers.
__________________
Gone, But Never Forgotten.

ΜΟΛΩΝ ΛΑΒΕ

That which does not kill me....has made a grave tactical error.
Mad Dawg is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 01-06-2009, 05:15 PM   #2
tchapchap
Contributing Editor
Club Member
 
tchapchap's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2003
Location: Right here
Posts: 4,273
Excellent stuff Doug, thanks!!

Gives me something to aspire to!
__________________
My Albums

(___|CW|_______))))~~~~

(unauthorized use of signature prohibited )
tchapchap is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 01-06-2009, 05:45 PM   #3
AnejoMofo
Club Member
 
AnejoMofo's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2007
Location: Live Free or Die!
Posts: 1,824
This is a great system and I'm happy to be a part of it.
__________________
Check out Blog of the Leaf!
FFF
GO PATS!!
"Always have cigars; the rest you can fix." -Ernesto Padilla
_______
RIP Cubano67
AnejoMofo is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 01-06-2009, 06:54 PM   #4
SmoKerch
Herf God
 
SmoKerch's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2002
Location: Indiana
Posts: 23,420
Nice!

Thanks for sharing the info.
__________________
Kercheval Bros. LLP
Professional Procrastination Consultants
1 - (900) - GO# - SAND

The Great State of Confusion

Just because I may be paranoid, it doesn't mean there aren't people out there trying to get me.


"I remember when 'liberal' meant being generous with your own money."--Will Rogers.

Visit us on The Facebook: Kercheval Bros. Procrastination Consultants !
SmoKerch is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 01-07-2009, 02:13 PM   #5
ConMan
Contributing Editor
Club Member
 
ConMan's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: Too far from a trout stream
Posts: 4,190
Cool. Looking forward to the reviews
__________________
Let's go Bucs!

ConMan is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 01-07-2009, 04:39 PM   #6
ElkTwin
Guest
 
Posts: n/a
Thanks, Doug, for keeping us honest!
  Reply With Quote
Old 10-31-2009, 07:21 AM   #7
goclarkanderson
Starting Member
 
Join Date: Oct 2009
Posts: 6
All of you write great. Much thanks for your posts!
goclarkanderson is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 08-03-2010, 11:50 AM   #8
TommyBB
Editor-in-Chief
Herf God
 
TommyBB's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 1998
Location: Metairie, LA
Posts: 83,328
Finally published another panel review, today.
__________________

+In Memory of E.Guevara(Cubano67) A.Morris (Knife) D. Odom (dodom) D. Revermann (dgr) S.Bouchard (sb1396) M. Cole (Matt76) S. Faccenda (TOJE) R.Smith(IBMer) V.Vandermeer (van55)M.Davis(boxdoctor)S.Singer(bassman)K.Doetze l (drillrk1)D.Hart(garme1962)J.Coleman(John C 81)T.Gossett(Dartplayer1)J.Bolt (jb)E.J.Ferralles(CaballoPinto)M.Cataldo(FVFanMC) + Libby DeMers,MrsScarecrow, MrsCrimson, MrsPhilip, MrsDeriffe LB
+Connor Olson+Micah Kercheval+Maggie Bonefas (LittleMean)+


TommyBB is offline   Reply With Quote
Reply

Bookmarks
Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
More Blind Reviews Cigar #5 - Arturo Fuente Cuban Belicoso Sun Grown debaire Cigar Reviews 35 09-02-2006 05:37 AM
More Blind Reviews Cigar #2 - El Rey del Mundo Rectangulare debaire Cigar Reviews 20 08-28-2006 01:41 PM
More Blind Reviews Cigar #4 - Montecristo H2000 Mini Belicoso debaire Cigar Reviews 36 08-23-2006 09:49 AM
More Blind Reviews Cigar #3 - Carlos Torano Tribute '03 Torpedo debaire Cigar Reviews 33 08-18-2006 12:09 PM
More Blind Reviews Cigar #1 - Cuban Crafters Cabinet Selection Torpedo debaire Cigar Reviews 49 08-15-2006 07:24 AM


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 08:56 AM.