Cigar Weekly

unklebill · 04-17-2002, 03:34 PM

First I would like to thank all of the reviewers that contributed their time and cigars to this project!

The 858 Sungrown was the lowest rated cigar with a 25 and the Oliva O was the highest rated cigar with a 41.

Only Eduardo picked the cigar he donated (Oliva O) as his favorite.

The score average was pretty consistant for all reviewers:
Jojoscigars: 32
Eduardo: 31.6
Grinnin: 34.8
Unklebill: 33.8
Emind56: 36.6
This is somewhat surprising considering scores ranged from 14 - 49.

Here is a summary of the ratings we gave and who donated them:
(jojoscigars) 5 Vegas: 32
(eduardo) Oliva O: 41
(grinnin) Jr Ultimate: 34
(unklebill) HdM 135th Ann.: 36
(emind56) AF 858 Sungrown: 25

Again, thanks to all the reviewers and to everyone who read them.

BILL

"Lars: The Joe Camel of cigars"

04-17-2002, 03:34 PM	#1
unklebill Club Member Join Date: Jun 2000 Location: Lubbock, TX Posts: 1,194	First I would like to thank all of the reviewers that contributed their time and cigars to this project! The 858 Sungrown was the lowest rated cigar with a 25 and the Oliva O was the highest rated cigar with a 41. Only Eduardo picked the cigar he donated (Oliva O) as his favorite. The score average was pretty consistant for all reviewers: Jojoscigars: 32 Eduardo: 31.6 Grinnin: 34.8 Unklebill: 33.8 Emind56: 36.6 This is somewhat surprising considering scores ranged from 14 - 49. Here is a summary of the ratings we gave and who donated them: (jojoscigars) 5 Vegas: 32 (eduardo) Oliva O: 41 (grinnin) Jr Ultimate: 34 (unklebill) HdM 135th Ann.: 36 (emind56) AF 858 Sungrown: 25 Again, thanks to all the reviewers and to everyone who read them. BILL "Lars: The Joe Camel of cigars" __________________ BILL

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Email this Page
Display Modes
Switch to Linear Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode Threaded Mode